Thursday, September 17, 2009

Greg Heffley's Secret Childhood Identity

Hanging in my father's office is a poem. You have to look very closely to see that it is a poem because it is in the shape of a face. My face. I remember using a mechanical pencil to assure myself of those fine lines and writing in as minuscule letters as possible. When I had nothing more to say I complete strands of hair with hair hair hair hair hair.

Blue Lipstick and Technically, It's Not My Fault by John Grandits brought me back to a time in my life when I was overflowing with words and not too self-conscious to put them on paper. It takes a kind of bravery to put your intimate thoughts into a format meant to be read by others (or in the case of a diary one that could be read by others.) I think this is part of what makes these books so compelling. They are not just told in a child's voice, but are children's voices revealing intimate thoughts meant primarily for themselves to hear.

Each book represented a gender, which seems to be how the much of the course is laid out. I try to deny that such a gender divide exists when I teach not wanting the girls to feel they have to read Diary of a Teenage Witch instead of Harry Potter, but I suppose I must accept that especially at their developmental age, a lot is different. I'll save my thoughts on gender though for the graphic novels, which illustrate my thoughts more clearly (pun intended.)

I want to clear the air of rumors- at least in my school, at least in the fifth grade, kids LOVE poetry! They love breaking the rules of punctuation and left to right. They love making comparisons and being silly. They love reading a poem and imitating its rhythm. They love using poetry to tell us what they think. We have poetry slams in the fourth and fifth grade every year and Grandits' work is a great source for lessons and independent reading during that unit.

On a different note, Diary of a Wimpy Kid may have saved my life. I consider myself a skilled book dealer. I pride myself on drawing reluctant readers out of their holes and into our class library. When they whine, "I can't find anything I like," I put something in their hands that turns it all around. Except when it doesn't. Enter comics. Thank you Calvin and Hobbes for being witty and accessible. Thank you Fox Trot for featuring bickering siblings. Thank you Boondocks for being political and edgy. I know, I am woefully out of date but I just don't get into manga and kids find that on their own anyway. But what's a teacher to do when kids need to build stamina and experience whole paragraphs? Enter Diary of a Wimpy Kid. Greg Heffley is self-centered, mischievous, and in general a pretty bad role model, but so is Calvin. On the other hand they are both creative, pensive, and trying to survive school. Come to think of it there is quite the resemblance in the work they hand in to their teachers and in their perception of bullies. Watterson retired but I think it's safe to say that here we get a glimpse of Calvin in middle school. Our students get a glimpse into their own world from a humorous point of view.

4 comments:

  1. Great post. I loved what you said about Blue Lipstick, and I thoroughly agree. Kids love reading poems and writing poems and talking about them. Sometimes they find different pieces of the poems hilarious, sometimes a particular stanza stands out to them. But yes, I completely agree with you.

    And yes, comics are also a great way to reach out to reluctant readers. I'm not so sure if this is the case across the entire genre, but you picked out some real winners. From your list I'd say the appeal is probably a mix between the genre, the pictures and the humor. Kids loooooove humor, and Wimpy Kid and your other choices definitely bring that in.

    When I was a tween and an elementary school student I loved Snoopy and read all of the books from cover to cover. So I totally get this.

    Good work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Speaking of the literary value of Snoopy...the complete collection of the Peanuts strips has an introduction by Umberto Eco!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey this is great! I don't think I've ever read your writing except for in notes you passed me in the hall in school... So impressed and amazed! Is there anything you can't do Ms Moon???

    ReplyDelete
  4. Correction: I was referring to Diary of a Fairy Godmother by Madame Esme. Oops!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.